Buy wisely
Buy wiselyBuy wisely
For RetailersFor developers
  1. Home
  2. Health & Beauty
  3. Hair Care
  4. Hair color
  5. L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
Buy wisely

BuyWisely is your one stop price comparison platform, delivering the best deals from over 20,000 online shops. We empower shoppers to make smart, cost-effective choices by offering transparent pricing, price history, and the latest deals across a broad range of products. With BuyWisely, your money goes further.

Popular Shops
JB Hi-Fi
The Good Guys
Harvey Norman
Appliances Online
Bing Lee
Kogan
Amazon
Officeworks
Contact Us
[email protected]
Affiliate Disclosure
Legal Information
Privacy Policy
Logos provided by Logo.dev
© 2026 BuyWisely•Price data powered by pricesAPI.io•Retailers: SellWisely.io

Price comparison

Price data powered by pricesAPI.io

Last updated at 21/11/2026 08:45:31

Please note: price history and price alerts are not available for some stores, including Amazon.com.au.
https://www.google.com/s2/favicons?domain=desertcart.com.au&sz=64desertcart.com.au

$29.80

Superior Preference Hair Color, 4SM Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

Delivery between 27 – 30 Nov $29

https://www.google.com/s2/favicons?domain=desertcart.ae&sz=64Desertcart.ae

$34.13

Superior Preference Hair Color, 4SM Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

Free delivery between 1 – 4 Dec

Price history

Price history

Please note: price history and price alerts are not available for some stores, including Amazon.com.au.

Reviews

DOES NOT COLOR AFRICAN AMERICA HAIR
15 October 2022River Queen 107

originally posted on Target

I purchased 91/2NB to color my gray hair and blend with my bleached light blonde hair. FYI, I have natural hair 3C - 4A which was recently cut short (2nd big chop). This product bleached my gray hair white and did NOTHING for my other hair. L’Oréal color is terrible. This is the second time it’s products have performed at subpar on my hair. I followed the directions exactly. Never again!

Inferior product (8.5A Champagne Blonde)
28 April 2021stormraven523

originally posted on Target

I don't know if I got a defective kit, but this product did pretty much nothing on my hair. I got it with the understanding that the result would be slightly redder than the swatches, as I was using this to reduce a brassy faded red color that did not take and lighten my light brown hair to a strawberry blonde. My original shade does, in fact match the light brown swatch on the product. However, after application, there was very little difference in the result and certainly nowhere near the lighter blonde swatch that was shown on the package. The product did not thicken very quickly when mixed (which is unusual for hair color but not unexpected as some color mixes will thicken a lot whereas some will thicken very little) and turned to a gel-like consistency after ... MoreI don't know if I got a defective kit, but this product did pretty much nothing on my hair. I got it with the understanding that the result would be slightly redder than the swatches, as I was using this to reduce a brassy faded red color that did not take and lighten my light brown hair to a strawberry blonde. My original shade does, in fact match the light brown swatch on the product. However, after application, there was very little difference in the result and certainly nowhere near the lighter blonde swatch that was shown on the package. The product did not thicken very quickly when mixed (which is unusual for hair color but not unexpected as some color mixes will thicken a lot whereas some will thicken very little) and turned to a gel-like consistency after approximately 10 minutes. The product shows a 1-3 level lift on light brown to blonde hair. This product did not provide even a 1 level lift on my hair, which has always been very easy to color, even with this product line in other shades. Honestly, I could have gotten a better result with a product like 'Sun-in'. So I was very disappointed in this product and would not recommend 8.5A Champagne Blonde to anyone needing a light brown/dark blonde to a lighter blonde result. It did not work and wasted my time and money.

Lackluster
14 May 2023Paigepaige

originally posted on Target

For the price, I thought this would be better. I had to purchase 2 boxes to cover my whole head. I processed for 25 minutes and the color was barely adjusting. I rinsed after and applied the conditioner and blow dried my hair and it looks fine but it’s uneven. It was almost impossible to completely saturate my hair without having the dye fall or slip off mid application. Won’t buy again. I thought this might be better than the Clairol Demi perm that I’ve used the last few times but no. And my hair isn’t ashy- it’s more of a chocolate or purpley brown.

Specification

Product TypeHair color
Area of ApplicationHair
Suitable Hair TypesAll
Sulfate-FreeYes
Paraben-FreeYes

Price comparison

Updated about 12 hours ago
Please note: price history and price alerts are not available for some stores, including Amazon.com.au.
https://www.google.com/s2/favicons?domain=desertcart.com.au&sz=64
desertcart.com.au

$29.80

Superior Preference Hair Color, 4SM Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

Delivery between 27 – 30 Nov $29

https://www.google.com/s2/favicons?domain=desertcart.ae&sz=64
Desertcart.ae

$34.13

Superior Preference Hair Color, 4SM Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

Free delivery between 1 – 4 Dec

Price history

Price history

Please note: price history and price alerts are not available for some stores, including Amazon.com.au.

Reviews

DOES NOT COLOR AFRICAN AMERICA HAIR
15 October 2022

I purchased 91/2NB to color my gray hair and blend with my bleached light blonde hair. FYI, I have natural hair 3C - 4A which was recently cut short (2nd big chop). This product bleached my gray hair white and did NOTHING for my other hair. L’Oréal color is terrible. This is the second time it’s products have performed at subpar on my hair. I followed the directions exactly. Never again!

River Queen 107 originally posted on Target
Inferior product (8.5A Champagne Blonde)
28 April 2021

I don't know if I got a defective kit, but this product did pretty much nothing on my hair. I got it with the understanding that the result would be slightly redder than the swatches, as I was using this to reduce a brassy faded red color that did not take and lighten my light brown hair to a strawberry blonde. My original shade does, in fact match the light brown swatch on the product. However, after application, there was very little difference in the result and certainly nowhere near the lighter blonde swatch that was shown on the package. The product did not thicken very quickly when mixed (which is unusual for hair color but not unexpected as some color mixes will thicken a lot whereas some will thicken very little) and turned to a gel-like consistency after ... MoreI don't know if I got a defective kit, but this product did pretty much nothing on my hair. I got it with the understanding that the result would be slightly redder than the swatches, as I was using this to reduce a brassy faded red color that did not take and lighten my light brown hair to a strawberry blonde. My original shade does, in fact match the light brown swatch on the product. However, after application, there was very little difference in the result and certainly nowhere near the lighter blonde swatch that was shown on the package. The product did not thicken very quickly when mixed (which is unusual for hair color but not unexpected as some color mixes will thicken a lot whereas some will thicken very little) and turned to a gel-like consistency after approximately 10 minutes. The product shows a 1-3 level lift on light brown to blonde hair. This product did not provide even a 1 level lift on my hair, which has always been very easy to color, even with this product line in other shades. Honestly, I could have gotten a better result with a product like 'Sun-in'. So I was very disappointed in this product and would not recommend 8.5A Champagne Blonde to anyone needing a light brown/dark blonde to a lighter blonde result. It did not work and wasted my time and money.

stormraven523 originally posted on Target
Lackluster
14 May 2023

For the price, I thought this would be better. I had to purchase 2 boxes to cover my whole head. I processed for 25 minutes and the color was barely adjusting. I rinsed after and applied the conditioner and blow dried my hair and it looks fine but it’s uneven. It was almost impossible to completely saturate my hair without having the dye fall or slip off mid application. Won’t buy again. I thought this might be better than the Clairol Demi perm that I’ve used the last few times but no. And my hair isn’t ashy- it’s more of a chocolate or purpley brown.

Paigepaige originally posted on Target
Loreal Paris Superior Preference
20 September 2022

I usually like Loreal. I use a lot of their products however this is one time I must say they truly missed the mark. I've noticed "Silver" has become quite popular these days and thought I would give it a shot. Needless to say I was very disappointed, especially considering how much it cost. All it did to my hair is remove what little gray that I had. My color is still it's natural color, medium brown.

Marcie originally posted on cvs.com
Professional Hair Colorist
8 October 2022

I thought the product was magnificent. The one application was enough to cover my entire head from root to end and when my hair is wet it lands on my shoulders and I have naturally curly hair. I have tons of white hair or with some would call grey very heavy in the front. I have been ill and having colored my hair in 6 months. My hair is naturally black but at 55 I want it to go lighter without anything pulling red. The results are absolutely stunning. Again more than enough color cover all my hair from root to end professional disposable gloves that are easy to take on and off, and a great tube of conditioner that can last me for about three applications. My hair is so soft and shiny and the color Blended beautiful with my already black hair considering I had about ... MoreI thought the product was magnificent. The one application was enough to cover my entire head from root to end and when my hair is wet it lands on my shoulders and I have naturally curly hair. I have tons of white hair or with some would call grey very heavy in the front. I have been ill and having colored my hair in 6 months. My hair is naturally black but at 55 I want it to go lighter without anything pulling red. The results are absolutely stunning. Again more than enough color cover all my hair from root to end professional disposable gloves that are easy to take on and off, and a great tube of conditioner that can last me for about three applications. My hair is so soft and shiny and the color Blended beautiful with my already black hair considering I had about 4 in of regrowth and another 6 in of black hair it Blended in beautifully.

Yvette originally posted on cvs.com
Shine Serum formula is a problem
13 May 2023

Like many other customers, I've used Loreal Preference (medium blonde) for probably 25 years, both Preference and Excellence, and it has always worked great. I get many compliments on my hair color, and people think it's natural. About a year ago I got a box with "Shine Serum" and I noticed right away that coverage was inferior and significantly lighter in color. I had to color again much sooner than usual. I made sure to avoid the Shine Serum boxes after that and had no more trouble. But I just colored my hair and the color (which was a weird red color, not at all like normal) didn't take at all. Not one bit. It's like I didn't just spent an hour and a half coloring my hair! I examined the box and sure enough, I found Shine Serum in tiny print, barely noticeable, ... MoreLike many other customers, I've used Loreal Preference (medium blonde) for probably 25 years, both Preference and Excellence, and it has always worked great. I get many compliments on my hair color, and people think it's natural. About a year ago I got a box with "Shine Serum" and I noticed right away that coverage was inferior and significantly lighter in color. I had to color again much sooner than usual. I made sure to avoid the Shine Serum boxes after that and had no more trouble. But I just colored my hair and the color (which was a weird red color, not at all like normal) didn't take at all. Not one bit. It's like I didn't just spent an hour and a half coloring my hair! I examined the box and sure enough, I found Shine Serum in tiny print, barely noticeable, which I totally missed. It was previously featured prominently. I feel tricked, like L'Oreal is trying to unload this unfortunate formula. And now I've got to color my hair again. What a shame, and waste of my time. I believe the entire problem is the Shine Serum formula. They need to get rid of it. I will continue to use the other formulas. Just beware of the Shine Serum!

LW originally posted on Target
Soft brown will turn hair black
10 October 2022

I had my hair bleached at a salon, after few months the contrast of the natural dark brown roots and the blond hair looked unpleasant to me. I made a very bad decision to color everything medium brown, and I thought how hard it could be. I don’t need to go to the salon. I got this box, and applied it according to the instruction, oh the smell of chemicals!!! I left it on the toots for 20min and on the blond hair for 5 minutes, guess what? My hair, dark brown root and the remaining blond part turned completely black, like really REALLY black. What is this garbage?

Peggy originally posted on Target
TURNED HAIR BLACK
2 May 2023

I was so excited to try this color because it looked like a beautiful rich brown (soft mahogany brown). I had level 6 hair and wanted a slightly deeper brown with a red undertone. it turned my hair completely BLACK. My hair also had a red undertone so their color was just not at all what was marketed. now I'm at a level 2 and am forced to ruin my hair by lifting the color out. never buying again this is the first time I've had EVER had a problem with any box dye. stick to garnier

DO NOT BUY MAHOGANY originally posted on Target
Will not adequately cover gray hair!
15 May 2023

I've used Loreal hair color for nearly a decade, but something in this formula has changed. Lately, I have tried repeatedly to cover my gray roots to no avail. This hair dye no longer covers gray. I've followed the instructions and even tried adding a few additional minutes to see if that would penetrate my hair better. Nope! This product is expensive and the color used to stay fairly vibrant for 6 or more weeks. This "improved" or watered down version of the original fades more quickly. So, I stuck paying more. Honestly, I've used Loreal for so long, that I'm afraid to switch brands. Yes, I am using the best color for my hair, but I can't rid myself of my gray roots.

sbj originally posted on Target
hair color
4 September 2022

Other than a salon this has been my go to color brand for many years. It has full coverage, a thick formula for easy application and low odor. It does not include an applicator brush instead it has a small top for better control. The grey coverage lasts about 5 weeks but if it's only partial you can go longer. I usually go about 6-8 wks. It's a good product to save money. The after color conditioner is fantastic and I highly recommend using a small amount a few times a week after you color for prolonging the color and keeping your hair frizz free.

Redd originally posted on cvs.com

Specification

Product TypeHair color
Area of ApplicationHair
Suitable Hair TypesAll
Sulfate-FreeYes
Paraben-FreeYes

You may also like

L'Oreal Paris Superior Preference Fade-Defying + Shine Permanent Hair
L'Oreal Paris Superior Preference Fade-Defying + Shine Permanent Hair$27.00
From Ubuy Australia
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

(25,241 reviews)

L'Oreal Superior Preference Hair Color – our gold standard in luxurious permanent hair color since 1973. Superior Preference at-home hair coloring kit is special because it delivers super shiny luminous hair color. Preference gives you long lasting hair color that’s fade-defying for weeks and weeks. From root to tip whether you have blonde hair%2C brown hair%2C black hair or red hair color%2C your color won’t look dull or brassy. Preference is available in over 50 Luminous Shades. Our Luminous Blonde shades range across a wide spectrum from light blonde to dirty blonde%2C honey blonde to red blonde and strawberry blonde to champagne blonde. Our rich Brown shades range across the spectrum of ash brown to sun-kissed caramel brown. Our deep Red shades range from dark red to auburn and copper to mahogany to burgundy. Each shade is crafted to show infinite tones and reflects%2C so you can find your own Superior Preference signature.

L'Oreal Superior Preference Hair Color – our gold standard in luxurious permanent hair color since 1973. Superior Preference at-home hair coloring kit is special because it delivers super shiny luminous hair color. Preference gives you long lasting hair color that’s fade-defying for weeks and weeks. From root to tip whether you have blonde hair%2C brown hair%2C black hair or red hair color%2C your color won’t look dull or brassy. Preference is available in over 50 Luminous Shades. Our Luminous Blonde shades range across a wide spectrum from light blonde to dirty blonde%2C honey blonde to red blonde and strawberry blonde to champagne blonde. Our rich Brown shades range across the spectrum of ash brown to sun-kissed caramel brown. Our deep Red shades range from dark red to auburn and copper to mahogany to burgundy. Each shade is crafted to show infinite tones and reflects%2C so you can find your own Superior Preference signature.

$29.80 - $34.13

in 2 offers

The lowest price for L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown right now is $29.80 at desertcart.com.au, compared across 2 retailers.

The all-time low was $17.82 on 23 July 2023 — today's price is 67% above the lowest ever. It has been notably cheaper before — worth setting a price alert.

Prices last updated 21 Nov 2026.

Colour:

L'Oreal Superior Preference Fade-Defying Permanent Hair 4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown

$29.80

(25,241 reviews)

L'Oreal Superior Preference Hair Color – our gold standard in luxurious permanent hair color since 1973. Superior Preference at-home hair coloring kit is special because it delivers super shiny luminous hair color. Preference gives you long lasting hair color that’s fade-defying for weeks and weeks. From root to tip whether you have blonde hair%2C brown hair%2C black hair or red hair color%2C your color won’t look dull or brassy. Preference is available in over 50 Luminous Shades. Our Luminous Blonde shades range across a wide spectrum from light blonde to dirty blonde%2C honey blonde to red blonde and strawberry blonde to champagne blonde. Our rich Brown shades range across the spectrum of ash brown to sun-kissed caramel brown. Our deep Red shades range from dark red to auburn and copper to mahogany to burgundy. Each shade is crafted to show infinite tones and reflects%2C so you can find your own Superior Preference signature.

L'Oreal Superior Preference Hair Color – our gold standard in luxurious permanent hair color since 1973. Superior Preference at-home hair coloring kit is special because it delivers super shiny luminous hair color. Preference gives you long lasting hair color that’s fade-defying for weeks and weeks. From root to tip whether you have blonde hair%2C brown hair%2C black hair or red hair color%2C your color won’t look dull or brassy. Preference is available in over 50 Luminous Shades. Our Luminous Blonde shades range across a wide spectrum from light blonde to dirty blonde%2C honey blonde to red blonde and strawberry blonde to champagne blonde. Our rich Brown shades range across the spectrum of ash brown to sun-kissed caramel brown. Our deep Red shades range from dark red to auburn and copper to mahogany to burgundy. Each shade is crafted to show infinite tones and reflects%2C so you can find your own Superior Preference signature.

3c Cool Darkest Brown
4 Dark Brown
4a Dark Ash Brown
4r Dark Auburn
4sm Dark Soft Mahogany Brown
5a Medium Ash Brown
5cg Iced Golden Brown
7la Lightest Auburn
9 Natural Blonde
Lb02 Extra Light Natura
Rr04 Intense Dark Red

Color:

8 Medium Blonde
9a Light Ash Blonde
Brown
Medium Golden Brown