Pick Your Poison
Would you rather be unable to cross the street without holding someone’s hand or be allergic to every food that contains the letters “A” or “E”? This is just one of the tough decisions you’ll have to make in Pick Your Poison – the game of diabolical dilemmas! The game’s simple to play. First, the judge picks 2 scenarios and answers everybody’s questions about them. Second, everybody anonymously picks the poison they’d rather live with. To score, you need to vote with the majority of the players. So, not only do you have to think about which scenario you’d rather endure, you have to guess what everyone else might choose, undergoing literally seconds of ‘will they, won’t they?’ torture as you do. So, if you know 3 to 16 people of any age, you’re in for 30 to 60 minutes of belly-laughs and blushing! So, to have more fun with poison than an evil fairy-tale queen, order your Pick Your Poison party game today!
Would you rather be unable to cross the street without holding someone’s hand or be allergic to every food that contains the letters “A” or “E”? This is just one of the tough decisions you’ll have to make in Pick Your Poison – the game of diabolical dilemmas! The game’s simple to play. First, the judge picks 2 scenarios and answers everybody’s questions about them. Second, everybody anonymously picks the poison they’d rather live with. To score, you need to vote with the majority of the players. So, not only do you have to think about which scenario you’d rather endure, you have to guess what everyone else might choose, undergoing literally seconds of ‘will they, won’t they?’ torture as you do. So, if you know 3 to 16 people of any age, you’re in for 30 to 60 minutes of belly-laughs and blushing! So, to have more fun with poison than an evil fairy-tale queen, order your Pick Your Poison party game today!
Would you rather be unable to cross the street without holding someone’s hand or be allergic to every food that contains the letters “A” or “E”? This is just one of the tough decisions you’ll have to make in Pick Your Poison – the game of diabolical dilemmas! The game’s simple to play. First, the judge picks 2 scenarios and answers everybody’s questions about them. Second, everybody anonymously picks the poison they’d rather live with. To score, you need to vote with the majority of the players. So, not only do you have to think about which scenario you’d rather endure, you have to guess what everyone else might choose, undergoing literally seconds of ‘will they, won’t they?’ torture as you do. So, if you know 3 to 16 people of any age, you’re in for 30 to 60 minutes of belly-laughs and blushing! So, to have more fun with poison than an evil fairy-tale queen, order your Pick Your Poison party game today!
Would you rather be unable to cross the street without holding someone’s hand or be allergic to every food that contains the letters “A” or “E”? This is just one of the tough decisions you’ll have to make in Pick Your Poison – the game of diabolical dilemmas! The game’s simple to play. First, the judge picks 2 scenarios and answers everybody’s questions about them. Second, everybody anonymously picks the poison they’d rather live with. To score, you need to vote with the majority of the players. So, not only do you have to think about which scenario you’d rather endure, you have to guess what everyone else might choose, undergoing literally seconds of ‘will they, won’t they?’ torture as you do. So, if you know 3 to 16 people of any age, you’re in for 30 to 60 minutes of belly-laughs and blushing! So, to have more fun with poison than an evil fairy-tale queen, order your Pick Your Poison party game today!
in 5 offers
The lowest price for Pick Your Poison right now is $27.09 at Good Games, compared across 5 retailers.
The all-time low was $6.94 on 20 Nov 2025 — today's price is 290% above the lowest ever. It has been notably cheaper before — worth setting a price alert.
Prices last updated 25 Sept 2026.
Last updated at 25/09/2026 19:23:36
Pick Your Poison -Family Edition
Free delivery
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a small commission for purchases made through this link at no extra cost to you. This helps support our site. Thank you!
Pick Your Poison
Delivery between 30 Sept – 8 Oct $9.50
Pick Your Poison Card Game
Delivery $12
Pick Your Poison
Delivery $9.99
Pick Your Poison Book by Dyce Games
Delivery between Tue – Wed $9.99
originally posted on Target
If you've played the "Would you rather" games out there, you know what this is about. You are forced to pick between two horrible possibilities. Dyce Games switched it up by letting players pick the two options! With hundreds of cards the possible combinations are insane, and we've played this game at least a dozen times, never having the two cards combined. It's a blast!
originally posted on walmart.com
The cards with 'would you rather' questions will have everyone laughing, to say the least. This game is great fun, easy to play, and will have everyone laughing and glad someone coupd come up with the questions that sometimes are surprising and always funny.The game is in a compact black box, easy to take anywhere and also store with ease.I definitely recommend this game to anyone wanting a fun yet easy game that will keep the group in stitches.
originally posted on walmart.com
I wanted to try out a new card game for our game night/ girls night with my friends for awhile and thought this new "Pick Your Poison Card Game: The What Would You Rather Do?" Party Game looked pretty fun. It is basically like "would you rather" game and the best card wins. It is simple and easy to set up and bring in new friends to the game once you get started. Just pick the best response you think everyone would rather "deal" with and play your chance. Then whoever had the best response wins that round. Super fun when you just want to kick back and relax and have a full evening with some friends or family. Easy to use and get the hang of for sure, but may not be suitable for kids is all. That's what makes it a fun party game amongst adults, you never know what ... MoreI wanted to try out a new card game for our game night/ girls night with my friends for awhile and thought this new "Pick Your Poison Card Game: The What Would You Rather Do?" Party Game looked pretty fun. It is basically like "would you rather" game and the best card wins. It is simple and easy to set up and bring in new friends to the game once you get started. Just pick the best response you think everyone would rather "deal" with and play your chance. Then whoever had the best response wins that round. Super fun when you just want to kick back and relax and have a full evening with some friends or family. Easy to use and get the hang of for sure, but may not be suitable for kids is all. That's what makes it a fun party game amongst adults, you never know what kind of crazy poison you or your party guests will have to choose from.
| Number of Game Players | 3-16 Players |
| Assembly Required | No |
| Language | English |
| Product dimensions | 10.11 x 7.59 x 19 cm; 750 Grams |
| Age range (description) | 156 months to 1188 months |
Pick Your Poison -Family Edition
Free delivery
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a small commission for purchases made through this link at no extra cost to you. This helps support our site. Thank you!
Pick Your Poison
Delivery between 30 Sept – 8 Oct $9.50
Pick Your Poison Card Game
Delivery $12
Pick Your Poison
Delivery $9.99
Pick Your Poison Book by Dyce Games
Delivery between Tue – Wed $9.99
If you've played the "Would you rather" games out there, you know what this is about. You are forced to pick between two horrible possibilities. Dyce Games switched it up by letting players pick the two options! With hundreds of cards the possible combinations are insane, and we've played this game at least a dozen times, never having the two cards combined. It's a blast!
The cards with 'would you rather' questions will have everyone laughing, to say the least. This game is great fun, easy to play, and will have everyone laughing and glad someone coupd come up with the questions that sometimes are surprising and always funny.The game is in a compact black box, easy to take anywhere and also store with ease.I definitely recommend this game to anyone wanting a fun yet easy game that will keep the group in stitches.
I wanted to try out a new card game for our game night/ girls night with my friends for awhile and thought this new "Pick Your Poison Card Game: The What Would You Rather Do?" Party Game looked pretty fun. It is basically like "would you rather" game and the best card wins. It is simple and easy to set up and bring in new friends to the game once you get started. Just pick the best response you think everyone would rather "deal" with and play your chance. Then whoever had the best response wins that round. Super fun when you just want to kick back and relax and have a full evening with some friends or family. Easy to use and get the hang of for sure, but may not be suitable for kids is all. That's what makes it a fun party game amongst adults, you never know what ... MoreI wanted to try out a new card game for our game night/ girls night with my friends for awhile and thought this new "Pick Your Poison Card Game: The What Would You Rather Do?" Party Game looked pretty fun. It is basically like "would you rather" game and the best card wins. It is simple and easy to set up and bring in new friends to the game once you get started. Just pick the best response you think everyone would rather "deal" with and play your chance. Then whoever had the best response wins that round. Super fun when you just want to kick back and relax and have a full evening with some friends or family. Easy to use and get the hang of for sure, but may not be suitable for kids is all. That's what makes it a fun party game amongst adults, you never know what kind of crazy poison you or your party guests will have to choose from.
Definitely an adult game that I would not want teenagers to play. My main criticism is that the statements are almost all surrounding sexual content. There are dilemmas in real life that would make better variety and conversations easier. Thought this would be a way to get to know people better but this game in itself falls short of that.
This was a fun party game. It would be good for an after-work game as well. Definitely for adults and older teens. I wouldn't feel comfortable playing this game with kids around. The best part is that it's pretty quick and won't get boring. The average game lasts 15 to 30 minutes. This would make a good gift as well.
We played this during Thanksgiving and man it was so much fun. When you have to pick your poison you really learn alot about your family & friends. We laughed so much at some of the poisons we picked that now they are running jokes.If you like game nights definitely add this to your Adult Game Night and then sit back and enjoy. We even went out and bought the family version. Definitely a game to add to your household collection.
Omg we were dying laughing at some of these choices! It’s hilarious to hear what your friends would choose and hear them rationalize it. It is obviously NSFW and fun to mix this with the original game too. The game board itself is great quality and was surprised to see that included, nice touch. The “judge” who picks the cards can elaborate and give any extra details they’d like for the cards which is a fun rule
Super fun game! The game board that you place the cards on is great quality. The family friendly original version is still a lot of fun to play with adults and has some tough comparisons. It’s even great to alter a bit to play with as little as two people, giving a lot of unique would you rather type of questions. We had a lot of fun playing this with friends, perfect for holiday parties!
Pick Your Posion is a cute mixture of Would You Rather and Apples to Apples. This version is family friendly and says it’s rates for ages 10 and up. Up to 10 people can play however more technically could if you made more A and B cards and a Double Down cards if needed. You can keep score the way it tells you to or just use the cards to play as ideas for would you rather to do this or that. There are some tough choices, just have to remember it’s a game and it isn’t actually going to happen.
I really enjoyed this game! The first time we played, we ended up going through the whole box of scenarios. We got a lot of laughs out of it and would love to play this during future gatherings as well. There are endless possibilities! But I do recommend playing with a group. I'm sure you will enjoy this. Some of these scenarios were just plain weird (or gross), but it made for interesting conversation and laughter! I would recommend this to others.
| Number of Game Players | 3-16 Players |
| Assembly Required | No |
| Language | English |
| Product dimensions | 10.11 x 7.59 x 19 cm; 750 Grams |
| Age range (description) | 156 months to 1188 months |
