Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter 510g

On its own, this is the best peanut butter on the market. It has just the right amount of sugar to still be sweet, while maintaining the flavor of the peanut. It’s impeccably creamy, creamier than the competition. That’s all reflected in the price, unfortunately, as it consistently goes for more than the other brands. It’s also much harder to find; I could only find it in a local Costco and various online stores. Still, if you can get your hands on it, you’re in for a PBnJ fit for royalty.

This is my SO's favorite peanut butter. I personally think it's a little sweet, it definitely tastes like there's some powdered sugar mixed in there, if you've ever eaten a chocolate buckeye before you know what I mean. I do appreciate this peanut butter for what it is, but I don't know if I could make it into a PB J sandwich for example. I do like to purchase it when I'm making cookies from scratch though because it does add a really nice flavor to the dough.

I absolutely love peanut Butter. If I could only have one food for the rest of my life it would be Peanut Butter. This Peanut Butter is just a little bit different then the rest. It is extremely creamy and just taste so amazing. I could eat the whole jar in one sitting. When I purchase Reese's Peanut Butter I have to buy a couple at a time. I eat it with a spoon. If you do want to make a PBJ it spreads on the bread so easily not ripping the bread. You can add this to ice cream, you can add it to smoothies or make delicious Peanut Butter Cookies. There is so much you can do with this Peanut Butter. I highly recommend this!!!

BEST PEANUT BUTTER EVER

i first tried this a few years back that i saw at my local walmart. i was hooked from the first taste. unfortunately for me i couldn't find it any more there or anywhere else. i stumbled on it a few weeks ago so now i'm set. i read all the negative reviews and don't agree with any. this tastes exactly like the peanut butter in a peanut butter cup. i cant get enough of this and it makes peanut butter and banana spectacular. give yourself a treat and get this. you will not and can not be disappointed. thanks to reeses for great product.

Delicious!

The amount of people assuming this would be the same as the peanut butter cup filling is amusing. Have you ever looked at the peanut butter filling? It’s delicious but it’s extremely dry and almost crumbly. It’s meant to be in a peanut butter cup and that’s it. You would not be able to spread it if it came in a jar. And it’s lack of moisture would not hold up well in a recipe. But as someone else stated this very unfortunately doesn’t surprise me though.

Good, but better with honey added to jar.

I still like the Great Value 7 g Protein Honey Roasted Creamy Peanut and Honey Spread, 16 oz. better. The Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter, I did not care for the taste. I added some honey to it and was a lot better. Have to admit that Reese's is much smoother to spread on crackers and creamier than Great Value.

So SAD!

So very sad! It’s just regular peanut butter. I didn’t think to check the reviews before buying because it’s Reeses! The master, Peanut Butter King on high! Why would I question their peanut butter performance?? I suppose I should have. And it’s not that y’all have never made anything that I don’t like some of the quirky Reese’s peanut butter cups versions I am not a fan of, some of absolutely love, although my personal favorite is and probably always will be Reese’s pieces. My husband lives for holidays because he knows he will be getting a ton of Reese’s candy. I invented a new peanut butter cake this summer that is spectacular if I do say so myself on the first run I used Jif natural creamy with honey in the filling and topped off with Reese’s peanut butter ... MoreSo very sad! It’s just regular peanut butter. I didn’t think to check the reviews before buying because it’s Reeses! The master, Peanut Butter King on high! Why would I question their peanut butter performance?? I suppose I should have. And it’s not that y’all have never made anything that I don’t like some of the quirky Reese’s peanut butter cups versions I am not a fan of, some of absolutely love, although my personal favorite is and probably always will be Reese’s pieces. My husband lives for holidays because he knows he will be getting a ton of Reese’s candy. I invented a new peanut butter cake this summer that is spectacular if I do say so myself on the first run I used Jif natural creamy with honey in the filling and topped off with Reese’s peanut butter baking chips (which DO taste like Reese’s candy) and it was an absolute smash hit. Since I’m making it again for Thanksgiving, I thought I would up the ante and buy the Reeses peanut butter spread too as aforementioned, nothing beats the flavor of Reese’s candy. Imagine my shock when I tasted it and it is just regular peanut butter! And just to make sure that I wasn’t being too picky I did a side-by-side taste test of the Reese’s baking chips, the straight Reeses peanut butter and Skippy all natural honey peanut butter. Baking chips were loved all day long The other two are interchangeable. Which means I paid significantly more for some thing subpar. I don’t have time to go back to the store so I’m going to have to just use this and explain before serving because everyone knew I was upgrading to the Reeses peanut butter. Super bummed guys. Please, please, PLEASE read all of these comments, as you said forward them on to the appropriate departments and then continuously follow up with the department badgering the heck out of them until they recognize our plate and start selling actual Reeses peanut butter!!! Apologies for the lengthy rant, thank you for your time and have a great day!

Tastes like Store Brand

Nothing special. Not bad. Just tastes like store brand at double the price. Well, the store brands do have honey Roasted peanut butter which are amazing! Reeses peanut butter tastes like regular store brand peanut butter. Nowhere close to the amazing honey Roasted store brand peanut butter.

Used to be my favorite Peanut Butter

I don't know what has changed, but my last 2 jars of Reeses Peanut Butter has been more like Peanut sauce. I can't even make a decent sandwich because it just runs out between the bread. I even tried refrigerating it, didn't help.I started buying Reeses because it was the only Peanut butter that didn't give me heartburn. But what good it when I can turn up the jar and pour my Peanut butter on my bread, no knife required?

Was expecting it to taste like PB in Reese’s Cups

Doesn’t taste like Reese’s peanut butter at all. Taste like regular peanut butter which to that regard it’s good. However I was expecting to be like the peanut butter that is in the Reese’s peanut butter cups. That would have been amazing. Like why pay extra for regular peanut butter?