Revlon ColorStay Makeup Combination/Oily Skin Buff

I was recommended this foundation for cosplay purposes due to its large shade range and affordable price. When I purchased this in the shade Oatmeal, I wasn't expecting it to match me perfectly since I had been shade matched with a different shade on the Revlon website, but it was on sale and I figured I could at least test the formula before giving it to someone else. Turns out that it matches me perfectly if I'm not trying to brighten my skin, which is exactly what I was aiming for. I'm naturally cool toned and pale but live in a sunny area where my warm, tan overtone can make finding foundation matches difficult. The formula itself is very nice. The foundation is fairly liquid, not a super thick consistency, which allows me to paint it on in thin layers on my ... MoreI was recommended this foundation for cosplay purposes due to its large shade range and affordable price. When I purchased this in the shade Oatmeal, I wasn't expecting it to match me perfectly since I had been shade matched with a different shade on the Revlon website, but it was on sale and I figured I could at least test the formula before giving it to someone else. Turns out that it matches me perfectly if I'm not trying to brighten my skin, which is exactly what I was aiming for. I'm naturally cool toned and pale but live in a sunny area where my warm, tan overtone can make finding foundation matches difficult. The formula itself is very nice. The foundation is fairly liquid, not a super thick consistency, which allows me to paint it on in thin layers on my skin. After setting for a bit, it stays on very well, and can be built up with another thin brushed or sponged layer for extra coverage. It works so well with any silicone based primer (I use elf's poreless putty primer) and lasts a long time. When it does come off, it doesn't break as much as just disappear, which I prefer as it looks cleaner at the end of the day

BEST FOUNDATION EVER.

This is the best foundation I’ve used in my life. I’ve gone to Ulta and bought the “expensive” foundations (Fenty, NARS, Estee lauder [did i even spell that right?]). I’ve also tried the “popular” drugstore ones (elf glow, fit me, cover girl, etc) anyways. They have ALL broken apart after about 4-5ish hours. Especially around the nose / mouth. I would have to carry the foundation in my car, remove my nose/mouth foundation and reapply. Sometimes I’d reapply 2x if it was a long day. And honestly i was so over it. I stopped wearing make up for awhile because i was tired of reapplying. Worrying if my make up was gonna be broken apart and I’d be outside looking like a clown. Now I am OILY. After 30 min my nose is oily and it’ll rub off on my hands, clothes etc. i carry ... MoreThis is the best foundation I’ve used in my life. I’ve gone to Ulta and bought the “expensive” foundations (Fenty, NARS, Estee lauder [did i even spell that right?]). I’ve also tried the “popular” drugstore ones (elf glow, fit me, cover girl, etc) anyways. They have ALL broken apart after about 4-5ish hours. Especially around the nose / mouth. I would have to carry the foundation in my car, remove my nose/mouth foundation and reapply. Sometimes I’d reapply 2x if it was a long day. And honestly i was so over it. I stopped wearing make up for awhile because i was tired of reapplying. Worrying if my make up was gonna be broken apart and I’d be outside looking like a clown. Now I am OILY. After 30 min my nose is oily and it’ll rub off on my hands, clothes etc. i carry tissues in my car to blot it out. With that said. i HAAATE “dewy” foundations because after an hour i shine like a disco ball. THIS foundation has lasted me ALLLLLL DAY AND I STAY MATTE. light shine, honestly to be expected but no breakage in coverage. I’m talking about i applied it @ 6 am and it is on my face at 10 PM. I HAVE SLEPT IN THIS MAKE UP AFTER A NIGHT OF DRINKING, and i woke up flawlessssssssss. You don’t need to reapply. A oil pad to absorb some oil then dab some Powder and it looks like you just applied it. I’ve honestly gone all day without touch ups and it was still good. But for flawless touch and go once a day. I’ve also got a perfect shade match with this foundation. I’m beyond thrilled. I 100% recommend this. The photo i attached is after i wore it for 16 hours. 6am - 10 PM. in California heat.

BRING BACK SOFTFLEX COLORSTAY

Revlon, what can I say! Your Softflex Colorstay foundation was my best companion for over 10 years! You stood with me through many all nighters out with my friends, crying at my wedding, many tropical (aka humid) and ski (aka dry) vacations! You kept me feeling flawless and beautiful! I loved you and wouldn’t leave the house without you. Then, something happened, imposters! They say it’s still you, but it’s no where close. I may be able to handle close, but I’m talking this new JUNK is so far from the mark. You were PERFECT the way you were. They butchered you and I have been mourning you for years now. Each time they change the package, I pray you in all your original glory have returned. Not yet, but I keep hoping and praying!Estée Lauder is close, but still ... MoreRevlon, what can I say! Your Softflex Colorstay foundation was my best companion for over 10 years! You stood with me through many all nighters out with my friends, crying at my wedding, many tropical (aka humid) and ski (aka dry) vacations! You kept me feeling flawless and beautiful! I loved you and wouldn’t leave the house without you. Then, something happened, imposters! They say it’s still you, but it’s no where close. I may be able to handle close, but I’m talking this new JUNK is so far from the mark. You were PERFECT the way you were. They butchered you and I have been mourning you for years now. Each time they change the package, I pray you in all your original glory have returned. Not yet, but I keep hoping and praying!Estée Lauder is close, but still isn’t nearly as good as you, Softflex Colorstay. You had liquid gold! Please please please bring it back! I’ll buy it all up (just in case you discontinue it again) and I know others will too!

Gives SoftFlex vibes ♥♥♥

*** Product bought with my own money ***(I don't trust reviews on products received as gift, too often they are offered in exchange for fake high rating. I don't do this, I purchase my products, thus my reviews are truly my own, without compromises).Application method : spongePROS :- slightly thicker-than-liquid texture that glides easily on skin,- stays true-to-tone once set,- dries neither too fast nor to slowly,- sets to a natural matte finish,- better shine control than the previous formula, though not as outstanding as the SoftFlex formula,- only minor creasing,- good transfer-resistance (although not astonishing),- ALMOST fragrance-free,- long-lasting.CONS :- slightly creases and settles into fine/expression lines IMMEDIATELY after application ... More*** Product bought with my own money ***(I don't trust reviews on products received as gift, too often they are offered in exchange for fake high rating. I don't do this, I purchase my products, thus my reviews are truly my own, without compromises).Application method : spongePROS :- slightly thicker-than-liquid texture that glides easily on skin,- stays true-to-tone once set,- dries neither too fast nor to slowly,- sets to a natural matte finish,- better shine control than the previous formula, though not as outstanding as the SoftFlex formula,- only minor creasing,- good transfer-resistance (although not astonishing),- ALMOST fragrance-free,- long-lasting.CONS :- slightly creases and settles into fine/expression lines IMMEDIATELY after application which requires immediate setting with powder on some areas like under the eyes, forehead and smile lines,- medium coverage at best,- non-calibrated shades between "oily" and "dry" formulas,- erratic pattern in the shade range and in the numbering systemCOMMENTS :I have very oily skin but I can wear indifferently this foundation in both Oily/Combination skin and Normal/Dry skin formulas. Honestly, calling one for oily skin and the other one for dry skin is a nonsense as the latter is not moisturizing in the least, in my opinion these are just twice the same product with only a few tweaks in the formulas to produce slighty different finishes and coverage levels.I’ve been using Colorstay for 16 years (I began with the SoftFlex formulas when they lauched in 2008). The SoftFlex formula was outstanding, it had iron-like lasting power and was 100% transfer-resistant. Then came the Time Release formula in 2011 (a complete formula change, especially the emulsifying ingredients)… and my 3 years love-story stopped there as the 2011 formulas (both "oily" and "dry") were absolutely horrendous on me, creasing like crazy and transferring onto everything like they never actually set. Between 2011 and 2022 there were some tweaks in the formulas but nothing major nor noticeable.This 2022 formula for oily skin is actually an improvement (for me) over the previous formula. It's better long-lasting and better transfer-resistant than the previous formula, though not quite as good as the SoftFlex formula.As usual, I wear the shade 150 Buff in the "oily" formula, as this has always been my best match. The match is so outstanding than if I miss an area I don't see anything weird, I don't see the foundation at all when I apply it on an area without redness, and on redness-prone area I've just the feeling I'm applying a redness eraser. None of Revlon's competitors has ever produced such a pale shade with olive undertone, most of the time they are too orange or too pink (when I'm lucky I find a true yellow based formula taht I can wear, but it's rare).It has a slightly thicker-than-liquid texture that glides easily on skin (even when spread with a brush). I do prefer a sponge as it meshes better with the skin. It dries neither too slowly nor too fast (and never to the point it flash-dries upon contact with the skin, like a competitor's formula do). It sets to a natural matte finish (more matte than the previous formula), which is an improvement as it is designed for oily skins with unwanted shine.During the setting time it tends to slightly crease on some areas like under the eyes (I don't use concealer, foundation is enough), on the forehead and the smile lines (mine are almost non existent but the slightest creasing emphasizes that this area is not as young as it used to be 20 years ago). So, once blended I dab a clean brush (or my finger) remove any excess product and speed-up the setting process (finger is better for this point), then immediately set with a translucent loose powder. I don't rush to powder the rest of my face as no creasing occurs anywhere else.The color ever-so-slighly darkens during the setting time (which is common, so don't rely on wet swatches to choose your match) but it's barely noticeable with this new formula. Then it stays true-to-tone during its weartime, The previous formula also used to redden while setting, this one doesn't.The shine control is good and, as strange as it sounds, is better with "dry" formula because of its powdery finish. The former Softflex formula for oily skin was much more absorbent and had a far better shine control.Although the word "fragrance" do not appear in the ingredient lists, both formulas are fragranced as they contain ethylene brassylate. While this ingredient gives a gorgeous warm, comforting distinct smell, neither flowery nor sugary (it’s found in many foundations from Revlon and competitors) it does not have any other purpose than perfuming. Fortunately, the smell is much lighter than it used to be and is now barely noticeable (I have a sensitive nose, I smell it but it's much much lighter than before). Nonetheless it’s something to note for the most sensitive skins/eyes amongst us.The shades are not calibrated between "oily" to "dry" formulas. As an example, Buff in "oily" formula tends to be more olive and half a shade lighter than Buff in "dry" formula.And finally a comment on the chaotic numbering system. The pattern in the shades range has always been the same : the smaller the number the lighter the shade, the bigger the number the darker the shade. But with some new shades launches that occured a few years ago, this pattern is not reliable anymore. I tried the shades 135 Vanilla and 140 Oatmeal, thinking they would be at least as pale as 150 Buff as their numbers are smaller… but nope, they are at least 2 shades darker. On the arms swatches pictures provided by Revlon, the shades are not even listed in ascending order of numbers, and the "smaller number but darker shade" occurs for many other shades than mine.Colorstay has made a huge come back in my bathroom for the better (and everyday use) ♥♥♥

Horrible new formula

Definitely a new formula. I came here to see if I was crazy and luckily all of the reviews agree, there is a new formula and it is not good. I’ve used this foundation for a long time and it covered very well, blended well and didn’t dry fast. Which made it have this great satin finish that wasn’t oily looking. I bought sand beige and not only is it darker and more orange, it drys immediately and I can barely apply it to my face in time, so it’s splotchy looking. It’s also very matte and I did get the oily/combo type but never used to be this thin and matte. I have tried using it with nothing on my skin and using it with moisturizer serums and primer with the same result. Please fix it

Last all day

I can swim, sweat, do anything and this foundation holds up! I have always used the combination oily kind, so it will be more of dry feeling , once it dries - vs the normal to dry kind, which aims to be a little moisturizing, but my preference , it seems a little too moisture, and doesn't seem to stay put as the other kind. When you apply it, try to go fast, you don't have to go Super fast. But, once you start to apply, continue till your done. Once you are to done, don't try to go back over it, with the foundation itself, it will come off (.Not with water or swear tho!! :)If you need to fix an area, best bet to use soap and water to wash off, and reapply. Oh shake well too. I always use any kind of powder over the foundation when I'm done. But it's fine if you ... MoreI can swim, sweat, do anything and this foundation holds up! I have always used the combination oily kind, so it will be more of dry feeling , once it dries - vs the normal to dry kind, which aims to be a little moisturizing, but my preference , it seems a little too moisture, and doesn't seem to stay put as the other kind. When you apply it, try to go fast, you don't have to go Super fast. But, once you start to apply, continue till your done. Once you are to done, don't try to go back over it, with the foundation itself, it will come off (.Not with water or swear tho!! :)If you need to fix an area, best bet to use soap and water to wash off, and reapply. Oh shake well too. I always use any kind of powder over the foundation when I'm done. But it's fine if you don't use power

NEW is NOT BETTER

I hav used Colorstay Longwear Combination/Oily Skin Makeup for years!!! I just purchased "The New" without knowing and instantly upon using it I knew something had changed!! After a week of using I had to look up and see what happened... and this is where I looked up to see. Sure enough, Revlon had to change an already great product. This no longer goes on smoothly, even after putting on a moisturizer before! The pump even dispenses a huge glob, way more than needed because it's too thick. So very disappointing. Sorry Revlon,I will be in search of an new foundation. No one wants their makeup to look caked on, which is how it looks now. This used to be such a great product, with a great price. Goodbye Revlon :(

New Formula

I have used Revlon Colorstay for years. I don't use a lot of makeup; the Colorstay Longwear Makeup is all have used for many years. When I bought my latest bottle, it appeared to be the same as I had been using-24 hrs 220 Normal to dry skin.The first time I wore the new product was Sunday to church. When I got home I noticed a fine rash on my face. I washed my face and by evening the rash was gone. Since I was going out on Tues. I applied it again. I had not associated the makeup to the rash.However after I had worn it for a few hours the rash reappeared. I fished my empty bottle from the garbage and compared the two labels. At first I didn't notice a difference.I then noticed the cap,was printed Hyaluronic Acid. This may be something my skin is sensitive ... MoreI have used Revlon Colorstay for years. I don't use a lot of makeup; the Colorstay Longwear Makeup is all have used for many years. When I bought my latest bottle, it appeared to be the same as I had been using-24 hrs 220 Normal to dry skin.The first time I wore the new product was Sunday to church. When I got home I noticed a fine rash on my face. I washed my face and by evening the rash was gone. Since I was going out on Tues. I applied it again. I had not associated the makeup to the rash.However after I had worn it for a few hours the rash reappeared. I fished my empty bottle from the garbage and compared the two labels. At first I didn't notice a difference.I then noticed the cap,was printed Hyaluronic Acid. This may be something my skin is sensitive to.Does Revon make a comparable product without this ingredient? I have been using Revlon for so long,I hate to have to change brands at my age.Thank you for your assistance. Jeannie

Still bad !!

*** Product bought with my own money ***(I don't trust reviews on products received as gift, too often they are offered in exchange for fake high rating. I don't do this, I purchase my products, thus my reviews are truly my own, without compromises).Application method : spongePROS :- slightly runny (almost oily) texture that glides easily on skin,- stays true-to-tone once set,- dries neither too fast nor to slowly,- sets to a powdery finish with tiny shimmers,- only minor creasing,- good transfer-resistance (although not astonishing),- ALMOST fragrance-free,- long-lasting.CONS :- powdery/chalky/dry-looking finish (whatever the application method is, sheerer with a sponge) that emphasizes flakiness and dry patches (which is not what dry skins need),- ... More*** Product bought with my own money ***(I don't trust reviews on products received as gift, too often they are offered in exchange for fake high rating. I don't do this, I purchase my products, thus my reviews are truly my own, without compromises).Application method : spongePROS :- slightly runny (almost oily) texture that glides easily on skin,- stays true-to-tone once set,- dries neither too fast nor to slowly,- sets to a powdery finish with tiny shimmers,- only minor creasing,- good transfer-resistance (although not astonishing),- ALMOST fragrance-free,- long-lasting.CONS :- powdery/chalky/dry-looking finish (whatever the application method is, sheerer with a sponge) that emphasizes flakiness and dry patches (which is not what dry skins need),- non-stabilized formula,- leaves specks of unblended pigments on the face,- slightly creases and settles into fine/expression lines IMMEDIATELY after application which requires immediate setting with powder on some areas like under the eyes, forehead and smile lines,- sheer-to-light coverage at best,- non-calibrated shades between "oily" and "dry" formulas,- erratic pattern in the shade range and in the numbering systemCOMMENTS :I have very oily skin but I can wear indifferently this foundation in both Oily/Combination skin and Normal/Dry skin formulas. Honestly, calling one for oily skin and the other one for dry skin is a nonsense as the latter is not moisturizing in the least, in my opinion these are just twice the same product with only a few tweaks in the formulas to produce slighty different finishes and coverage levels.I’ve been using Colorstay for 16 years (I began with the SoftFlex formulas when they lauched in 2008). The SoftFlex formula was outstanding, it had iron-like lasting power and was 100% transfer-resistant. Then came the Time Release formula in 2011 (a complete formula change, especially the emulsifying ingredients)… and my 3 years love-story stopped there as the 2011 formulas (both "oily" and "dry") were absolutely horrendous on me, creasing like crazy and transferring onto everything like they never actually set. Between 2011 and 2022 there were some tweaks in the formulas but nothing major nor noticeable.This 2022 formula for dry skin is not a real improvement over the previous formula.It has a slightly runny texture that glides easily on skin (even when spread with a brush). I do prefer a sponge as it meshes better with the skin. It dries neither too slowly nor too fast (and never to the point it flash-dries upon contact with the skin, like a competitor's formula do). It sets to a powdery finish (weird) which is a nonsense for dry skins.During the setting time it tends to slightly crease on some areas like under the eyes (I don't use concealer, foundation is enough), on the forehead and the smile lines (mine are almost non existent but the slightest creasing emphasizes that this area is not as young as it used to be 20 years ago). So, once blended I dab a clean brush (or my finger) remove any excess product and speed-up the setting process (finger is better for this point), then immediately set with a translucent loose powder. I don't rush to powder the rest of my face as no creasing occurs anywhere else.The color ever-so-slighly darkens during the setting time (which is common, so don't rely on wet swatches to choose your match) but it's barely noticeable with this new formula. Then it stays true-to-tone during its weartime, The previous formula also used to redden while setting, this one doesn't.The shine control is good and, as strange as it sounds, is better with this formula (because of its powdery finish) than the oily skin formula. The former Softflex formula for dry skin was much smoother and had a far better lasting power.Let's note that this formula has a problem that the "oily" formula doesn't share : the pigments stick onto the inner surface of the bottle, giving the illusion it's always full (even when the bottle is actually empty). As these pigments (especially the titanium dioxide) is not suspended in the formula anymore, the color seen from outside the bottle tends to become lighter (almost white) over time, while the actual product that's dispensed becomes darker and sheerer (even less than a tinted serum). The non blended pigments leaving huge white specks on the face in the former "dry" formula has only ever-so-slighty improved : I still see white specks, like tiny sand grains, but I admit that they are tinier than before (LOL).Although the word "fragrance" do not appear in the ingredient lists, both formulas are fragranced as they contain ethylene brassylate. Fortunately, the smell is much lighter than it used to be and is now barely noticeable (I have a sensitive nose, I smell it but it's much much lighter than before). Nonetheless it’s something to note for the most sensitive skins/eyes amongst us.The shades are not calibrated between "oily" to "dry" formulas. As an example, Buff in "oily" formula tends to be more olive and half a shade lighter than Buff in "dry" formula.And finally a comment on the chaotic numbering system. The pattern in the shades range has always been the same : the smaller the number the lighter the shade, the bigger the number the darker the shade. But with some new shades launches that occured a few years ago, this pattern is not reliable anymore. I tried the shades 135 Vanilla thinking it would be at least as pale as 150 Buff as its number is smaller… but nope, it is at least 2 shades darker. On the arms swatches pictures provided by Revlon, the shades are not even listed in ascending order of numbers, and the "smaller number but darker shade" occurs for many other shades than mine.Colorstay for dry skin won't get into my bathroom again until all the major problems are fixed.

What used to be a bestseller is now ruined

This used to be my holy grail foundation that none other could beat. I've used it for 15 years- the shade, longevity, cover everything was perfect but this new formula is like a completely different foundation. I have an old bottle in my summer shade 180 and my skin looks flawless with it while the new one feels like a random watered down foundation. I use the oily version and its no longer that much durabl and longwearing. I have to powder a lot more as it gets shiny quickly. And it just doesn't look that good on too. Revlon ruined their bestseller. Won't be repurchasing. it