These treats are not as described. They are solid balls that do not attract the dog's attention. My border collie will eat them if there is nothing else because he eats anything, but he does not view them as a treat. You can't use them for training things like loose lead walking when the dog is mobile as they are so hard

My 4 months old puppy tried a couple of them the night when we opened it for the first time then she ended up vomiting and terrible diarrhea next morning. We had to take her to emergency centre and she vomited once more in our car on the way to emergency. And the vet suspected this treat caused it all. I feel terrible that I got this for her.

Becomes Rocky's favourite too

My Rocky boy loves blackdog chicken Brest, but the meat ball is my first time order and no surprise my Rocky boy loves it too

Disappointed

Our 7 month old Toy Poodle found them too hard to chew and kept spitting them out. Couldn't eat them as they were hard side. Miss leading as they are not soft at all. Do not recommend for small puppy dog breads.

Disappointed

Ad says soft and chewy. Definitely not the case. Product is very hard. My 4 mth puppy ate 2 from a Kong then vomited then straight up. They were so hard she couldn’t chew them small enough and ended up choking on a piece. Would not recommend .

Dont Like these

My fussy small dog does not like hard biscuits and these are. I thought I was buying moist chews

Good treats, not for training treats

Although my dog seemed to like these treats, they are very chewy and hard which is time consuming. This means they are not appropriate as training treats but would be good for people who just like to give their dogs treats for fun. I am a bit disappointed as they were advertised as training treats but understand they are still a good product

Stubborn bulldog loves them

These treats peaks most stubborn British Bulldogs interest. My boy is generally not interested in treats and is not food obsessed so it became difficult to motivate him with food.. But not with these treats. As soon as I opened the packet he was at my feet, and when he knows I have one in my hand he's drooling everywhere. They are larger in size than I expected. About the size of a 20c coin. Will definitely buy these again.

Yum + Clean

My dog loves it. It's also a very 'clean' treat - no greasy feeling, minimal odour, and the size of each ball is great for most dog. However, I do have a chihuahua cross so I would actually prefer a smaller portion for my dog specifically. Otherwise they're great.

good treat, but slightly misleading description

my 11 month old border collie seems to love these treats. however, they are not soft and seem quite difficult to bite on. only recommend for older dogs or dogs that like to chew.