NZ's favourite peanut butter, made by the best Peanut Butter Makers. Legendary Hi Oleic peanuts, fresh roasted and lovingly squashed in sunny Nelson, NZ Freshly roasted in their oven, squashed in their squashers, and jarred by their jarrers at Pic’s Peanut Butter World in Nelson. A natural plant-based protein source. It’s 100% Hi Oleic peanuts with a dash of salt in here - no weird stuff.
NZ's favourite peanut butter, made by the best Peanut Butter Makers. Legendary Hi Oleic peanuts, fresh roasted and lovingly squashed in sunny Nelson, NZ Freshly roasted in their oven, squashed in their squashers, and jarred by their jarrers at Pic’s Peanut Butter World in Nelson. A natural plant-based protein source. It’s 100% Hi Oleic peanuts with a dash of salt in here - no weird stuff.
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
NZ's favourite peanut butter, made by the best Peanut Butter Makers. Legendary Hi Oleic peanuts, fresh roasted and lovingly squashed in sunny Nelson, NZ Freshly roasted in their oven, squashed in their squashers, and jarred by their jarrers at Pic’s Peanut Butter World in Nelson. A natural plant-based protein source. It’s 100% Hi Oleic peanuts with a dash of salt in here - no weird stuff.
NZ's favourite peanut butter, made by the best Peanut Butter Makers. Legendary Hi Oleic peanuts, fresh roasted and lovingly squashed in sunny Nelson, NZ Freshly roasted in their oven, squashed in their squashers, and jarred by their jarrers at Pic’s Peanut Butter World in Nelson. A natural plant-based protein source. It’s 100% Hi Oleic peanuts with a dash of salt in here - no weird stuff.
in 33 offers
The lowest price for Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g right now is $6.35 at GoPotatoes, compared across 31 retailers.
The all-time low was $3.75 on 26 Nov 2025 — today's price is 69% above the lowest ever. It has been notably cheaper before — worth setting a price alert.
Prices last updated 8 June 2026.
Last updated at 08/06/2026 15:51:25
Pic's Smooth Peanut Butter 380g
Delivery $23.91
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Free next-day delivery
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
30-day returns
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth | 380g
Delivery between Wed – Sun on orders of $50+
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g — Compare Coles vs Woolworths
Free next-day delivery
Pic's Really Good Peanut Butter Smooth 380gm
Next-day delivery $5
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Next-day delivery $10
originally posted on 177milkstreet.com
Excellent texture and flavor. Sweeter than any unsweetened peanut butter I’ve tasted before, which is nice. Although not as salty as I like for many uses (like eating by the spoonful) this makes it perfect for cooking and sauces. I’m glad I bought two jars.
originally posted on 177milkstreet.com
I have tried other natural peanut butters and didn't like the taste or consistency. This one is perfect! Taste is creamy and delicious. I saw a recipe on Rachel Ray, No Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Oat Protein Balls that I will be making with this peanut butter.
originally posted on 177milkstreet.com
Delicious peanut butter, but oil collects at the top of the jar. Annoying. I keep it in the refrigerator and have to try to stir it before I can spread it. Wouldn't buy it again because of this.
| Serving Size | 15g |
Pic's Smooth Peanut Butter 380g
Delivery $23.91
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Free next-day delivery
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Pic's Peanut Butter Smooth 380g
Excellent texture and flavor. Sweeter than any unsweetened peanut butter I’ve tasted before, which is nice. Although not as salty as I like for many uses (like eating by the spoonful) this makes it perfect for cooking and sauces. I’m glad I bought two jars.
I have tried other natural peanut butters and didn't like the taste or consistency. This one is perfect! Taste is creamy and delicious. I saw a recipe on Rachel Ray, No Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Oat Protein Balls that I will be making with this peanut butter.
Delicious peanut butter, but oil collects at the top of the jar. Annoying. I keep it in the refrigerator and have to try to stir it before I can spread it. Wouldn't buy it again because of this.
I am glad I bought this, as I do like to experience new flavors. The peanut flavor is stronger than typical grocery store peanut butter, and like natural peanut butters, you do need to stir it up before using. However, I did find it a little bitter. It wasn't that the flavor wasn't sweet enough, it seemed a tad bitter. As I said, it was a good experience, but I won't be buying it again.
Flavor is good, and it is healthier (at least as stated in the product information). My morning toast is with peanut ofr almond butter. This is where Pic's lowers its score. The peanut butter is not very thick and my favorite multi grain bread has small spaced out pockets that allow the peanut butter to ooze through them. I will try the crunchy next.
Did not mix together easily as stated, I.e. a couple stirs. Runny, flavorless. Milk Street Store does NOT accept returns unless the product is defective. As far as I’m concerned this product is defective. It is also misrepresented. If this product is misrepresented, how many others are? I will not buy from Milk Street again
From the promos I expected this to be the perfect peanut butter but its flavor is much less than expected. It is definitely healthier than the hydrogenated grocery store stuff but the richer flavor can be found in a handful of Aurora peanuts. Definitely not bad but less than was hoped for.
Not at all pleased. Product - best peanut butter ever but was suggested from the description ( that has now changed) made me believe I was ordering 4 jars. Having bought before at supermarket for 4 a jar I thought good value for money, plus unable to get it in shops, maybe due to Covid 19. However, parcel arrived, all excited, love peanut butter, especially this one JUST ONE JAR - 13.00 FOR JUST ONE JAR of peanut butter. Value for money - ABSOLUTELY RUBBISH!!!
Pics is the penultimate peanut butter: full roasted flavor, really smooth and not lumpy ( unlike other “natural” nut butters ). It tastes fresh and healthier than other brands. Wow, that Aussie peanut variety makes such a difference! I bought four jars when the shipping was free!
This is the best pnut butter ever. Our parrot loves it too! I have some daily. I always keep three in our larder. I highly recommend this pnut butter
| Serving Size | 15g |
